Impact Effort Matrix

sort options by impact and effort so a group agrees what to do first

Impact Effort Matrix
Description

What is an Impact Effort Matrix?

An impact effort matrix is a prioritisation tool that sorts options into four groups by how much they move the goal (impact) and how much time, money and people they need (effort). Each option goes on a sticky note, the group places the notes on a two by two grid, and the result shows what to do first (easy wins), what to plan for (big bets), what to fit in (add-ons), and what to drop (avoid).

It works because it splits one hard question ("which of these should we do?") into two easy ones, asked one at a time. And it turns a room full of opinions into a picture everyone can point at.

Explanation

How does an Impact Effort Matrix work?

Impact / Effort
1
Prepare⏱ 5 min

Write each option on its own note

Write every option on its own sticky note before the session, or collect them in the first ten minutes with a quick How Might We or brainstorm. Then close the list. The matrix is at its best as a deep conversation about a small, fixed set of options, about four, each defined clearly enough that nobody has to ask what it means. In our own sessions we rarely manage to place more than four with care; every note gets a real discussion, and that takes time. If you have twelve, prioritise first with a priority pyramid or a dot vote and bring only the survivors to the board. As soon as the definition work has to happen on the board ("what do we actually mean by this one?"), the session gets intense and slow.

Then agree what "impact" means today. Impact on revenue, on the team, on the customer? Pick one. If the room scores against different definitions, the matrix shows disagreement about words, not about options.

low efforthigh effort
2
Effort first⏱ 10 min

Sort every note by effort, and ignore impact

Draw one horizontal line, low effort on the left, high on the right. Take the first note, put it in the middle, and ask: how much time, money and people does this need? Take the next note and ask only whether it is more or less effort than the ones already there.

Doing one axis at a time is what makes the method work. Asking "where does this go?" invites a debate about everything at once.

Keep it relative. "More or less than that one?" is a question people can answer. "Is it a 7?" is not.
high impactlow impactlow efforthigh effort
3
Then impact⏱ 10 min

Move each note up or down

Now the vertical axis, impact. Start with the note on the far left and ask how much it moves the goal you agreed in step 1. Up for high, down for low. Work your way to the right.

Expect the notes to drift upward. Everyone's own idea is high impact, so a first pass often ends with the whole group in the top left corner. When that happens, split the axis into three bands, low, middle and high, and ask of each note which band it belongs in. Three bands force a choice that "a bit higher" does not.

If the group is large or senior, let everyone score silently first: each person writes an impact score on the note, then you place it by the average. The loudest voice places fewer notes that way.

highmiddlelow?
4
Check⏱ 5 min

Look at the board before you read it

Step back and look for three things. Notes stuck in the middle usually mean the option is too vague to score ("improve onboarding"), or two people disagree and settled on the middle: split the vague ones, put a question mark on the disputed ones and name the disagreement out loud. Notes on top of each other usually mean the clustering was skipped and two versions of one idea were scored separately: merge them. And a top left corner with everything in it means the scale was too kind: stretch it, as in step 3, and go again.

Then ask the room one question: "Is there anything here you would move?"

Easy winsshort-term moveBig betslong-term investmentAdd-onsnice to haveAvoidnot worth the costhigh impactlow efforthigh effort
5
Read the quadrants⏱ 5 min

Easy wins, big bets, add-ons and avoid

Top left, high impact and low effort: easy wins, the short-term moves. Do these first. Top right, high impact and high effort: big bets, the long-term investments. These need a plan, an owner and usually a decision from whoever holds the budget. Bottom left, low impact and low effort: add-ons, nice to have, fine for a quiet week. Bottom right, low impact and high effort: avoid. Not worth the cost. Drop them, or at least say out loud that nobody will do them.

You will meet the same four quadrants under other names: quick wins, major projects, fill-ins and thankless tasks. Our Miro template uses those and puts effort on the vertical axis. Either way round works, as long as the whole room reads the axes the same way.

The matrix informs the decision. It does not make it. A team can still choose a big bet over three easy wins, and often should.

WhoWhatWhen
6
Decide and allocate⏱ 10 min

Who does what, by when?

Everything before this step is decision informing. This step is the decision. A programme associate at a think tank described the alternative on one of our calls: "I don't even know that a decision was ever ultimately made."

Take the easy wins and the one or two big bets the group wants to pursue. For each, agree an owner, the first concrete step, and a date. Put the rest in a parking lot with a note on when it gets revisited.

Test: if an owner cannot say what they will do by Friday, the item is not ready to leave the board.

What it looks like on a wall

Three moments from one of our workshops in Washington DC. The sheet was ready before the group arrived: axes, quadrant names, and the question at the bottom, opportunities that can be accomplished within the next five years.

A flipchart impact effort matrix with the four quadrants drawn and a single sticky note placed in the easy wins quadrant
The first note goes up. It is placed against the axes, not against other notes, because there are no other notes yet. This is the easiest placement of the session and the one that sets the scale.
The same matrix with about twenty sticky notes, most of them crowded into the easy wins quadrant
Everyone's own idea is high impact and low effort, so the top left fills up. What we said to this group: it is tempting to rate everything as high impact, so imagine we could do only one thing. Then split the axis into low, middle and high bands and ask again.
A matrix with the notes spread across the board, several of them overlapping in the middle
More spread, but notes still sit on top of each other in the middle. Overlapping notes are usually two versions of one idea; merge them before you read the board.

Using it with senior people in the room

An impact effort matrix is the quietest way to disagree with the most senior person in the room. A talent director at a university put the usual problem well: "when we get into a decision space, it's very much like, all right, here's what matters to my area." Four habits make the matrix work when you are not the one who decides.

HabitWhy
Agree the criteria before anyone sees the optionsOnce a director has placed a note, the criteria tend to bend to fit it. Fix what "impact" means first, in writing, on the board.
Score alone, then place togetherSilent scoring gives you the real spread of opinion. Placing by average means the position belongs to the group, not to the person who spoke first.
Give the decision maker the last word, not the firstAsk them to come in once the board is full and choose between the easy wins and the big bets. Their authority is spent on the decision, not on the scoring.
Make the reasons visible when you voteIf you dot vote afterwards, use colours for the reason: one colour for revenue, one for the team, one for the customer. Add a question mark where someone has a doubt. People commit more to a decision when their hesitation was seen.

Common mistakes

Two lines from our orientation calls say what goes wrong. An HR director in an engineering company: "sometimes they're getting lost in details." A facilitator of executive teams: "Good session, but actually nothing changes." The first is a setup problem, the second is a step 6 problem. Check these before you start.

MistakeInstead
Scoring before the list is closedTwelve half-defined options on the board means the definition work happens there, and it gets intense. Prioritise down to about four first, and define each one.
Placing notes on both axes at onceEffort first, all notes. Then impact. One question at a time.
Options at different sizes"Redesign the website" next to "fix the login bug" cannot be compared. Break big options into pieces first, or run two boards.
"Impact" means something different to each personDefine it in step 1 and write it above the board.
Treating the board as the decisionThe matrix sorts. The group, or the decision maker, still chooses. Say who that is before you start.
Everything ends up as an easy winBoth scales are relative. If the whole board sits in the top left, split each axis into low, middle and high bands: the highest note is "high impact" by definition, and the rest are placed against it.

Variations

importanturgent

Urgency on a second board

Do not add urgency as a third axis. Once the board is read, place the easy wins and big bets the group wants on a second two by two: important on the vertical, urgent on the horizontal. The Eisenhower matrix, in other words. It answers a different question: not "is this worth it?" but "does it have to be now?" A big bet that cannot wait beats an easy win that can.

OptionCost ×2SpeedTotal64162594311

Weighted decision matrix

When two criteria are not enough. Options as rows, criteria as columns, a weight per criterion, and a score in every cell. Slower, and better for a decision the group has to defend later.

MustShouldCouldWon't

MoSCoW

Four buckets instead of a grid: must, should, could, won't. Faster, and better when the question is scope rather than order.

The matrix is one of the most useful tools we know for what we call decision informing: the work that happens before anyone decides. It makes the trade-offs visible without asking anyone to argue for or against a colleague's idea. The deciding still needs a method of its own, whether that is one person choosing, a vote, or a round of fist to five.

Lead Workshops with Senior Stakeholders

Techniques like this one are useful but we always recommend to zoom out. The Workshop Map shows where your group is and the best next step. Get it free, with a 5-day email course that walks you through.

RankingIdeasRefiningIdeasDiscussingIdeasGeneratingIdeasSharingOpinionsSharingExpertiseSharingFeedbackSharingProgressIdentifyingImprovementsReviewingProjectsAddressingTensionsAligning onGoalsPlanning theRoadmapChoosing bestoptionChallengingassumptionsExploringTrade-offsGeneratingSolutionsSharingInformationCreatingAlignmentMakingDecisionsThe team is here now
Dot voting
Everyone places a few dots. The most dots wins.
Consent
We go ahead unless someone has a real objection.
Majority
More than half agree, so we decide.
Example

What is a good example for an Impact Effort Matrix?

These are sessions people brought to our orientation calls this year, described the way they described them. The pattern repeats: a group with more options than capacity, a decision that has to leave the room, and often someone there who outranks the facilitator.

Session
Who is in the room
What is on the notes
What the matrix settles
Annual focus-setting workshop, HR leadership team of a global engineering contractor
Who is in the roomThe HR director, her leadership team, and the SVP whose agenda it is
What is on the notesCandidate focus areas for the year, which become the team's objectives
What the matrix settlesWhich three areas get the year's energy, and which wait
Research agenda day at an environmental think tank
Who is in the roomAbout 30 invited experts
What is on the notesResearch questions the institute could fund
What the matrix settlesWhich questions to pursue in the next year
Half-day offsite at a company in a technology transformation
Who is in the roomTeams pitching, and two leaders who hold the budget
What is on the notesImprovement ideas the teams want to pilot
What the matrix settlesThe two or three ideas that get funding and a 90-day pilot
Roadmap session run by the research team of a professional certification body
Who is in the roomFour product teams, more than 20 people
What is on the notesCustomer problems and features competing for the roadmap
What the matrix settlesWhat is built first, and what is parked with a date
Steering committee of chief sustainability officers at an international convening organisation
Who is in the roomThe CSOs, and the lead who convenes them without authority over them
What is on the notesPossible focus areas for a new work stream
What the matrix settlesWhere the work stream starts

In every one of these, the facilitator was not the most senior person present. That is normal, and it is why the steps above put the criteria before the opinions. This is what a finished board can look like in our Miro template, which puts effort on the vertical axis and names the quadrants quick wins, major projects, fill-ins and thankless tasks:

Origin

Who invented an Impact Effort Matrix?

The impact effort matrix has no single documented inventor. It is one of a family of two by two prioritisation grids that spread through management and quality circles in the 1980s and 1990s. The best-known relative is the Eisenhower matrix (urgent against important), popularised by Stephen Covey in The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People (1989). Impact against effort is the version that teams reach for when the question is "what do we build or change first?" rather than "what do I do today?".

Downloads

Impact Effort Matrix Template Download

Impact Effort Matrix PDF Template

To download the Impact Effort Matrix PDF Template, simply click the button below.

content_copy
Download PDF Template

Impact Effort Matrix Miro Template

  1. Click the button below, to open the Impact Effort Matrix Miro Template
  2. In Miro click on the name of the board in the upper-left corner, to see the board info card
  3. Click on the Duplicate button in the info card to add the template into your own account.
content_copy
Get Miro Template
Screenshot explaining how to duplicate a Miro template

Impact Effort Matrix Mural Template

  1. Click the button below, to open the Impact Effort Matrix Mural Template
  2. In the new tab click on Create mural from template to create a new Mural board with the template in your account

Tip: You can also click "Save for later" to save the template into your account and use it in the future.

content_copy
Get Mural Template
Screenshot explaining how to duplicate a Mural template
Live · Thursdays
Facilitator Masterclass

Get better at running sessions like this one

A template gives you the structure. Holding the room when a director pushes back, or when the group goes quiet, is a skill you build by practising. That's what our facilitation skills training is for.

6 weeksMax 12 peopleLive on ThursdaysBring a real session
See Facilitator Masterclass
FAQ

Questions & Answers

expand_more
How can I edit the Impact Effort Matrix template?
Duplicate either the Miro or Mural Impact Effort Matrix template. All you need for that is a free account on one of the platforms. From there you can fully edit and adapt the template content and colors to your own needs.
expand_more
Can I share the Impact Effort Matrix template with others?
Yes, absolutly! Feel free to share this template with your team, colleagues or organisation. The best way to do this, is to send them a direct link to the template.
expand_more
Is it possible to print the Impact Effort Matrix template?
Yes, you can print the Impact Effort Matrix template. To do so, simply download the PDF version of this template. The PDF version is in A4 format, vector-based and can be printed in high-quality on large size. The best paper size for printing is A1, because it's still portable but gives you enough space to work on.
expand_more
Do I need a payed Miro or MURAL account to use the Impact Effort Matrix template?
No, a payed Miro or Mural account won't be necessary to use this template, because you can always use the free plan for both tools. Or if you exceed the limits of the free plan, you can always download this template as a PDF.
expand_more
What is the license for this template?
This template is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0. In short that means, you are free to download, copy and share the template. But while doing so, you must give appropriate credit and provide a link to the Impact Effort Matrix template website.